Introduction

Cowboy butter is the perfect way to elevate any steak dish to new heights. Made with butter, garlic, lemon zest, Dijon mustard and fresh herbs – not only does it enhance steak but also chicken, seafood and vegetables!

This guide covers everything you need to know about cowboy butter for steak: its preparation, variations and storage tips as well as serving advice.

What is Cowboy Butter?

Cowboy butter is an irresistibly tasty combination of garlic-herb butter with a zesty kick. Originally used as a dip for grilled meats, its combination of buttery richness, citrus brightness and mild heat has since made it popular as a steak topping.

Key Ingredients in Cowboy Butter

• Butter – The base of cowboy butter, providing richness.
• Garlic – Adds a deep, savory flavor.
• Lemon juice & zest – Brightens up the butter with a citrusy touch.
• Dijon mustard – Gives it a slight tang and complexity.
• Fresh herbs – Parsley, chives, and thyme add freshness.
• Red pepper flakes – Introduces a mild heat.
• Worcestershire sauce – Enhances the umami and depth of flavor.

How to Make Cowboy Butter for Steak

Making cowboy butter at home is quick, easy, and incredibly rewarding. With just a handful of ingredients and 10 minutes of prep time, you can create a rich, flavorful butter that melts beautifully over a hot steak.

Ingredients for Cowboy Butter

To make the perfect cowboy butter, you need a combination of rich, creamy butter, bold seasonings, and fresh herbs. Here’s everything you’ll need:

Essential Ingredients:

• 1 cup unsalted butter, softened – The base of the recipe. Softening the butter ensures it blends well with the other ingredients.
• 3 cloves garlic, minced – Adds a deep, savory flavor that complements steak beautifully.
• 1 tbsp lemon juice – Brings a bright, tangy contrast to the richness of the butter.
• 1 tsp lemon zest – Enhances the citrus notes and freshens up the overall flavor.
• 1 tbsp Dijon mustard – Provides a subtle tang and depth to the butter.
• 1 tbsp fresh parsley, chopped – Gives a vibrant, herbaceous note.
• 1 tsp fresh chives, chopped – Adds a mild onion-like flavor that pairs well with steak.
• ½ tsp red pepper flakes – Introduces a touch of heat without overpowering the other flavors.
• 1 tsp Worcestershire sauce – Deepens the umami and adds a hint of smokiness.
• ½ tsp salt – Enhances all the flavors and brings everything together.
• ½ tsp black pepper – Adds a bit of spice and complexity.

Optional Ingredients for Extra Flavor:

• ½ tsp smoked paprika – Adds a smoky undertone, perfect for grilled steaks.
• 1 tsp chopped rosemary – Gives an earthy, pine-like aroma that pairs beautifully with beef.
• ½ tsp honey – A touch of sweetness to balance out the tanginess of the lemon and mustard.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Follow these simple steps to make cowboy butter:

Step 1: Soften the Butter

Remove the butter from the refrigerator 30-45 minutes before use and let it sit at room temperature. Softened butter blends more easily with the other ingredients. If you’re short on time, you can microwave it for 5-10 seconds, but be careful not to melt it.

Step 2: Prepare the Ingredients

• Mince the garlic finely to release its full flavor.
• Zest the lemon using a fine grater, ensuring you only get the yellow outer layer (not the bitter white pith).
• Chop the parsley and chives into fine pieces to distribute their flavors evenly throughout the butter.

Step 3: Mix the Ingredients

In a medium-sized bowl, combine:
✔ Softened butter
✔ Minced garlic
✔ Lemon juice & zest
✔ Dijon mustard
✔ Fresh parsley & chives
✔ Red pepper flakes
✔ Worcestershire sauce
✔ Salt & black pepper

Step 4: Blend Until Smooth

Use a fork, spoon, or hand mixer to thoroughly mix all the ingredients. The butter should become smooth, creamy, and evenly blended.

✔ If you prefer a chunkier texture, mix it gently with a fork.
✔ For a super smooth butter, use a hand mixer or food processor to whip it into a light, fluffy consistency.

Step 5: Shape the Butter

• Lay out a sheet of plastic wrap on a clean surface.
• Spoon the butter mixture onto the center of the plastic wrap.
• Roll the butter into a log shape, twisting the ends tightly to secure it. This makes it easy to slice into rounds later.

Step 6: Chill and Set

Place the wrapped butter log in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour (or 30 minutes in the freezer) to allow the flavors to meld together.

💡 Pro Tip: If you’re short on time, spread the butter in a small dish and place it in the fridge to harden quickly.

Step 7: Serve and Enjoy

Once the butter has firmed up, slice it into rounds and place them on your hot steak. As the butter melts, it will coat the meat in a rich, garlicky, herby sauce that enhances every bite.

The Best Steak Cuts to Pair with Cowboy Butter

Cowboy butter elevates any steak, but some cuts pair especially well due to their texture and marbling. Here are the best options:

1. Ribeye

✔ Best for: Grilling, pan-searing
✔ Why it works: High marbling makes ribeye incredibly juicy and allows it to absorb the rich flavors of cowboy butter beautifully.

2. Filet Mignon

✔ Best for: Pan-searing, reverse-searing
✔ Why it works: Filet mignon is naturally lean and tender, making cowboy butter the perfect addition to enhance its mild flavor and soft texture.

3. New York Strip

✔ Best for: Grilling, broiling
✔ Why it works: This cut is known for its firm texture and bold beefy taste, making it an excellent match for the robust flavors of cowboy butter.

4. T-Bone & Porterhouse

✔ Best for: Grilling
✔ Why it works: These larger cuts contain both tenderloin and strip steak, giving you the best of both worlds. The cowboy butter melts into the juicy meat, creating an irresistible flavor explosion.

Cooking the Perfect Steak for Cowboy Butter

Cowboy butter is packed with tasty, rich ingredients However, for it to show its full potential, you have prepare your meat in the correct way. By adjusting the timing, seasoning, along with the resting process you can guarantee an extremely tender and succulent steak when paired by cowboy butter.

1. Seasoning the Steak

The foundation of a cowboy steak starts with proper seasoning. Before cooking, season your steak generously to enhance its natural flavors and create a delicious crust.

Essential Seasonings:

• Salt – The most important ingredient. Salt draws out moisture, helping create a perfect sear while enhancing the beef’s flavor.
• Black Pepper – Adds a sharp, slightly spicy bite that balances well with the richness of the steak.

Additional Flavor Enhancers:

• Garlic Powder – Brings a warm, savory depth without the risk of burning fresh garlic.
• Smoked Paprika – Adds a mild smoky flavor, perfect for grilled steaks.
• Onion Powder – Complements garlic powder and enhances the meat’s umami.
• Crushed Red Pepper Flakes – For those who love a little heat.

💡 Pro Tip: Pat the steak dry with a paper towel before seasoning to ensure a better crust and even sear.

2. Choosing the Best Cooking Method

The right cooking technique depends on the cut of steak, desired doneness, and personal preference. Here’s a breakdown of the best cooking methods:

Method	Best For	Cooking Tips
Grilling	Ribeye, Strip, T-Bone	Use high heat to create a smoky, charred crust. Flip only once for even cooking.
Pan-Searing	Filet Mignon, Ribeye	Cook in a cast-iron skillet with high heat for a rich brown crust. Baste with butter for extra flavor.
Reverse Searing	Thick-Cut Steaks (1.5”+)	Slow-cook in the oven at 225°F before finishing with a high-heat sear. Ideal for medium-rare perfection.

How to Execute Each Cooking Method

Grilling:

✔ Preheat the grill to 450-500°F for high heat.
✔ Sear each side for 3-5 minutes, depending on thickness.
✔ Move to indirect heat and cook until desired doneness is reached.

Pan-Searing:

✔ Heat a cast-iron skillet on high until smoking hot.
✔ Sear the steak for 2-4 minutes per side, flipping once.
✔ Add butter, garlic, and fresh herbs in the last minute, basting the steak continuously.

Reverse Searing (Best for Thick Steaks):

✔ Preheat the oven to 225°F.
✔ Place steak on a rack over a baking sheet and slow cook until it reaches 10-15°F below the desired doneness (use a meat thermometer).
✔ Remove from the oven and sear in a smoking hot pan for 1-2 minutes per side.

💡 Pro Tip: Always use a meat thermometer for perfect doneness.

Doneness	Internal Temperature
Rare	120-125°F
Medium-Rare	130-135°F
Medium	140-145°F
Medium-Well	150-155°F
Well Done	160°F+

3. Resting the Steak

Resting the steak is just as important as cooking it. After removing it from the heat:
✔ Place the steak on a cutting board or plate.
✔ Cover loosely with foil to keep it warm.
✔ Let it rest for 5-10 minutes before slicing.

Why Resting is Important:

• It allows the juices to redistribute, making the steak juicier.
• Prevents juices from running out when cutting, keeping the meat tender.
• Ensures an even temperature throughout the steak.

💡 Pro Tip: Top the steak with a slice of cowboy butter while it rests. The warmth will melt the butter, creating a rich, flavorful sauce that seeps into the meat.

Variations of Cowboy Butter

Cowboy butter is incredibly versatile, and you can easily adjust the ingredients to create different flavor profiles. Here are some delicious variations:

1. Spicy Cowboy Butter 🔥

Perfect for those who love heat!
✔ Add 1 tsp hot sauce (such as Tabasco or Sriracha)
✔ Increase red pepper flakes to 1 tsp
✔ Add ½ tsp cayenne pepper for an extra kick

2. Smoky Cowboy Butter 🌿

Great for grilled steaks with a deep, smoky flavor.
✔ Add ½ tsp smoked paprika for a mild smoky taste
✔ Use chipotle powder instead of red pepper flakes for a rich, earthy heat
✔ Swap regular salt for hickory-smoked salt

3. Herbaceous Cowboy Butter 🌱

For a fresh, herb-forward twist.
✔ Double the amount of parsley, chives, and thyme
✔ Add 1 tsp fresh rosemary, finely chopped
✔ Mix in ½ tsp tarragon for a subtle licorice-like aroma

💡 Pro Tip: Try combining different variations! Smoky + Spicy cowboy butter is a game-changer for grilled steaks.

How to Store Cowboy Butter

Cowboy butter stores well, making it easy to have on hand for future steak nights.

1. Refrigeration 🧊

✔ Place the cowboy butter in an airtight container or keep it in a wrapped log shape.
✔ Store in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

2. Freezing ❄️

✔ Roll the butter into a log and wrap it tightly in plastic wrap.
✔ Place in a freezer bag or airtight container.
✔ Freeze for up to 3 months.

💡 How to Use Frozen Cowboy Butter:

• Simply slice off a piece as needed and place it on your hot steak.
• Let it melt over roasted vegetables, grilled shrimp, or even baked potatoes.

FAQ About Cowboy Butter

1. What is cowboy butter made of?

Cowboy butter is an irresistibly flavorful compound butter comprised of butter, garlic, lemon juice, Dijon mustard, fresh herbs, Worcestershire sauce with red pepper flakes, Worcestershire sauce with honey or hot sauce for additional depth and smoked paprika for additional depth. Rich and zesty yet slightly spicy in nature – making this perfect as an accompaniment for meats, seafood and vegetables cooked over an open flame grill!

2. Is cowboy butter good on steak?

Absolutely! Cowboy butter elevates the flavor of any steak by adding richness, tanginess, and spice. Garlic and herbs enhance its natural flavors while the butter melts into it seamlessly for a luxurious restaurant-quality experience. It goes particularly well with ribeye, filet mignon, New York strip, and T-bone steaks.

3. Which butter is best for steak?

The best butter for steak is unsalted, high-quality butter with a high butterfat content (82% or more). Unsalted butter allows better control over seasoning. For additional flavor, compound butters like cowboy butter, garlic herb butter, or truffle butter are excellent choices.

4. How to make a compound butter for steak?

Making compound butter for steak is quick and easy:
✔ Soften the Butter – Leave unsalted butter at room temperature for 30 minutes.
✔ Mix Ingredients – Combine softened butter with minced garlic, fresh herbs (parsley, chives, thyme), lemon zest, Dijon mustard, Worcestershire sauce, salt, and pepper.
✔ Blend Well – Mix with a fork or hand mixer until smooth.
✔ Shape and Chill – Roll the butter into a log using plastic wrap, twist the ends, and refrigerate for at least 1 hour before using.

💡 Pro Tip: Slice the chilled butter and place it on a hot steak right before serving for the best flavor and melt-in-your-mouth texture.

Conclusion

Cowboy butter is an irresistibly flavorful compound butter that elevates any steak to gourmet status. Boasting rich garlicky notes with just a hint of spice, cowboy butter enhances beef’s natural flavors while adding an irresistibly buttery bite – perfect for grilling ribeye, pan-searing filet mignon or reverse searing thick-cut steak! When applied properly it melts perfectly over meat for an authentic restaurant-quality experience right in your own kitchen!

Cowboy butter is quick and simple to make, with endless customization possibilities such as extra spice, smoky paprika or fresh herbs – not to mention it stores well both in the fridge and freezer so that you’ll always have some on hand for steak nights, seafood dinners or roast vegetables!

Cowboy butter adds the perfect finishing touch for an impressive steak experience in any dining setting, be it at home, a restaurant, or any special event! Make it and experiment with different variations for maximum steakhouse-quality results right in your own kitchen!

Looking for more inspiration? Check out Hyper Recipes on Pinterst and Follow us on Facebook for more delicious wild game and confort food recipes 🍽️🔥

Print